I need information on these books of Tafsir

[ummeesa]

Assalamu alaikum,

Can someone please provide information about these books of Tafsir. I want to know especially if they are acceptable in what they contain about 'aqeedah.

Ruh al-Ma’ani

Tafsir Abu al-Sa'ood

Bayan al-Quran by Hakim al-Umma

[Abu Alqamah]

Salam aleykum

Ruh Al-Ma'ani is written by Mahmud Al-Alusi Al-Hanafi, the Mufti of Ahnaf of his time,, and he is a famous scholar for opposing Quburiyah...

As for Bayan ul Quran of Thanvi, then Ashraf Ali Thanvi believes Majzub Awliya decide who the ruler will be, Allah can give Karamat to naked Sufis and people can come to these naked for their needs and others

So it is better to avoid such Tafseer

[ummeesa]

Jazzak Allahu khairan brother.

[Efendi]

Salam alaikum.

For Abu Suud check this link.
http://www.ahlalhdeeth.com/vbe/showthread.php?t=6350

[Abu Bakr b. Nasir]

The first two tafsirs are important and valuable references on the topic of Tafsir.

Alusi has some Sufi inclination in regards to certain aspects of his style of Tafsir but is otherwise a valuable tafsir.

Abu Su'ud is a mutakallim and so therefore his interpretations on verses that relate to Aqidah should be cautioned against. It would be preferable for you to study a strictly Sunni Tafsir and have some basic knowledge about the Aqidah of Ahl al-Sunna coupled with awareness about the beliefs of Ahl al-Kalam before relying too heavily on a book like this.

[Efendi]

Salam alaikum.

Yesterday i was presented by 7 volumes of incomplete commentary by Abu Muin Nasafe. Any idea? Is that a same who wrote akaid-nasafiyah? Maturudi?

And people please advice regarding commentary of Abu Bakr al-Jazairi. If man have Saade, Ibn Kathir, Jalalayn. Would he find something new in "Ayseratul tafaseer"?

[sumanang]

Bismillahirrahmanirrahim
Brother, what do you think about Tafseer Mahasinut Ta'wil (Al-Qasimiy). If you don't mind, please give me a complete comments about it. What is the valuable things in it which we haven't found in Thabary, Ibn Katseer and Qurthuby.

Regards

[Abu Bakr b. Nasir]

Originally Posted by Efendi

Salam alaikum.

Yesterday i was presented by 7 volumes of incomplete commentary by Abu Muin Nasafe. Any idea? Is that a same who wrote akaid-nasafiyah? Maturudi?

I'm not sure if he is the same, but the author is definitely from Ahl al-Kalam. If you have a good background in Sunni Aqida, and are familiar with the aqa'id of Ahl al-Kalam, you can safely benefit from such a work without being affected.

And people please advice regarding commentary of Abu Bakr al-Jazairi. If man have Saade, Ibn Kathir, Jalalayn. Would he find something new in "Ayseratul tafaseer"?[/quote]

Aysar al-Tafasir is an easy, summarized tafsir; easier than Jalalayn. His listing of fawa'id derived from each group of verses is also beneficial to refer to as well. Wallahu A'lam

Tafsir al-Tabari, al-Tahrir wal-Tanwir (by ibn Ashur), Tafsir al-Qurtubi, and Tafsir ibn Atiyya are essential works on the topic of Tafsir as well. However, for reference purposes, you can find them in Shamela if you don't care to buy them.

[Efendi]

Jazak Allah khayran akhee.